Rent vs Buy: How much equity could you build in Lloydminster?

Put in your own numbers and see the home equity you could build, next to the rent you would pay over the same years.

DK Real Estate GroupLPT Realty

Equity you'd build

After 5 years

Home equity

$67,446

Total rent paid

$124,234

After 10 years

Home equity

$143,123

Total rent paid

$268,255

After 25 years

Home equity

$467,573

Total rent paid

$853,147

Home equity is the home's value minus the mortgage left. It includes your down payment of $14,250.

Total rent paid includes a 3% yearly rent increase. Rent builds no equity.

Owning also has costs that build no equity (interest, property tax, insurance, maintenance): $196,452 over 10 years.

First year: of $18,702 in mortgage payments, $6,275 goes to principal (forced savings) and $12,427 to interest. Rent for the same year: $23,400, which builds no equity.

Monthly mortgage payment
$1,558.47

Cash to get in
$19,195

See the breakdown

Monthly payment

$1,558.47

Semi-annual compounding

Cash to get in

$19,195

All-in monthly

$2,212.52

Break-even

Buying pulls ahead of renting in year 4

Cash to get in

  • Down payment$14,250
  • Land titles transfer fee$335.00
  • Mortgage registration fee$335.00
  • Closing costs (1.5% of price)$4,275
  • CMHC premium, added to your mortgage$10,830

All-in monthly

  • Mortgage$1,558.47
  • Property tax$249.88
  • Insurance$166.67
  • Maintenance$237.50
  • Condo fees$0.00

After 10 years (your planned stay)

  • Home equity (home value minus mortgage left):$143,123
  • Home equity after selling costs:$125,752
  • Renting: invested savings would grow to:$47,193
  • Plus the buyer's invested savings:$5,688

Renting's figure assumes the renter invests the cash they didn't spend on a down payment, closing costs and any higher monthly costs.

YearHome equityEquity after selling costsRenting invested savings
5$67,446$51,713$36,667
10$143,123$125,752$47,193
25$467,573$444,194$98,112

These numbers are estimates for planning only and are not financial advice. Confirm rates with your lender and closing costs with your lawyer.

Edit assumptions

CMHC premium tiers (read only)

  • 2.80% with 15 to 19.99% down
  • 3.10% with 10 to 14.99% down
  • 4.00% with 5 to 9.99% down
  • Plus 0.20% over 25 years
  • None at 20% down

Neither Alberta nor Saskatchewan charges a land transfer tax. Each charges land titles fees, and they are calculated differently on each side. See the fee schedules.

Home equity vs total rent paid

Rent builds no equity. Owning has its own costs that build no equity, shown in the breakdown.

Buy and sell in 2 years

  • Home equity:$27,769
  • Home equity after selling costs:$12,944
  • Renting: invested savings:$27,360

Renting ahead by $14,417

Short stays usually don't pay off once buying and selling costs are counted.

Buy and keep for 10 years

  • Home equity:$143,123
  • Home equity after selling costs:$125,752
  • Renting: invested savings:$47,193

Buying ahead by $84,246

Home value then about $347,413, mortgage left about $204,291.

Buy, then keep it as a rental

Monthly rental cash flow: -$360.02

Landlord insurance and taxes on rental income differ from owning a home you live in.

Talk it through

I'm happy to walk through your numbers with you, no pressure.

Book a quick call with Dave

Or call or text 639-536-0401.

Want Dave to look at your numbers?

These numbers are estimates for planning only and are not financial advice. Confirm rates with your lender and closing costs with your lawyer.

Dave Kadun, LPT Realty